Product comparison
Collagen Boost vs Vital Proteins vs Ancient Nutrition
Melaleuca Collagen Boost, Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides and Ancient Nutrition Multi Collagen compared on added ingredients, container size and price.
Collagen Boost and Vital Proteins
Collagen Boost. Photo: melaleuca.com 
Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides. Photo: vitalproteins.com
Is Collagen Boost different from Vital Proteins?
Melaleuca's Vitality for Life Collagen Boost, Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides and Ancient Nutrition Multi Collagen Protein are collagen powders with different added ingredients. Collagen Boost is marketed with astaxanthin. Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides has an Advanced version that adds hyaluronic acid and vitamin C. Ancient Nutrition Multi Collagen Protein combines collagen with vitamin C and probiotics.
How the three powders compare
| Collagen Boost | Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides | Ancient Nutrition Multi Collagen Protein | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Collagen source | Not listed | Bovine hide | Not listed |
| Serving size | 12 g scoop | Not listed | Not listed |
| Protein per serving | 10 g | Not listed | Not listed |
| Calories per serving | 40 | Not listed | Not listed |
| Added ingredients | Astaxanthin | Hyaluronic acid, vitamin C (Advanced version) | Vitamin C, probiotics |
| Container size | 30 servings | 9.33 oz tub or 20 oz tub (with hyaluronic acid and vitamin C) | 45 servings |
| Price | $57.00 regular / $39.89 preferred member | $29.99 (9.33 oz with HA + vitamin C) / $49.99 (20 oz with HA + vitamin C) | $49.95 |
| Price per serving | $1.90 regular / $1.33 member | Not listed | $1.11 |
| How you buy | Melaleuca product store | Direct subscription or one-time purchase | Direct from maker |
Prices change, so check each maker's site for current pricing.
What is in each powder?
Melaleuca calls its product "Vitality for Life Collagen Boost with Astaxanthin." Melaleuca says the powder contains astaxanthin, and it also sells a "Ceramides" version with different additions.
The maker says Collagen Peptides contains "one single ingredient from upcycled bovine hide." Vital Proteins describes it as paleo- and keto-friendly, with no dairy, gluten, artificial sweeteners, colors or flavors. Its Advanced version adds hyaluronic acid and vitamin C.
Vital Proteins says its Collagen Peptides help support healthy hair, skin, nails, bones and joints. The maker says hyaluronic acid helps support skin hydration, and vitamin C can help promote collagen production and support a youthful appearance. Vital Proteins also says its Collagen Peptides mix easily into coffee, smoothies and other drinks.
Ancient Nutrition says its Multi Collagen Protein "uniquely combines responsibly sourced collagen, lipid-enhanced vitamin C and gut-resilient probiotics." Ancient Nutrition calls it a "6-in-1" formula for skin, hair, nails, joint, gut and immune support. The maker describes the daily supplement as research-driven and designed to support a proactive approach to whole-body wellness.
What does each serving cost?
Collagen Boost costs $57.00 for 30 servings at the regular non-member price. Preferred members pay $39.89 for the same 30 servings. That works out to $1.90 per serving at the regular price and $1.33 at the member price.
Vital Proteins lists the 9.33 oz tub at $29.99 and the 20 oz tub at $49.99, both with hyaluronic acid and vitamin C. A subscription cuts the price by 15%. Vital Proteins lists subscription delivery frequencies from one to eight weeks and says subscribers can cancel anytime.
At the single-tub price, Ancient Nutrition Multi Collagen Protein costs $1.11 per serving.
Where can you buy each powder?
Melaleuca sells Collagen Boost through its product store, with a lower price for preferred members. That setup may suit households already ordering several Melaleuca products.
Vital Proteins sells through its own site, with subscription or one-time purchase options. Vital Proteins subscribers get 15% off and free shipping over $50. The company says it has more than 25,000 monthly subscribers.
For more on Melaleuca supplements, see the vitamins and supplements section. The brand comparisons index has side-by-side pages for cleaners, laundry and skin care.
Which powder fits your household?
Households that already order from Melaleuca each month can get Collagen Boost for $1.33 per serving at the member price. It includes astaxanthin, with no extra shipment to manage.
For the lowest upfront price, Vital Proteins' 9.33 oz Collagen Peptides tub is $29.99, and a subscription takes 15% off that.
Ancient Nutrition's Multi Collagen Protein costs $1.11 per serving and combines several collagen sources with vitamin C and probiotics in one scoop.
Sources
- Melaleuca Vitality for Life Collagen Boost with Astaxanthin
- Melaleuca Collagen Boost nutrition facts, FatSecret
- Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides
- Ancient Nutrition Multi Collagen Protein
